After living in Thailand and now back in the US, it is difficult to find real Thai products like the ones we're used to and that are reasonably priced. I was happy to find these here and ordered two as gifts. They came just as expected and are beautiful. The shipping does take some time, so just be sure to order several weeks in advance if you are on a timeline. The flappers do not come attached but it was easy to clip them on. I believe the reviews that said they didn't have flappers just didn't realize this and likely missed seeing them in the packaging. We are very happy with our order. Thank you!